In an article titled, GIS, Public Service, and the Issue of Democratic Governance by Akhlaque Haque at the University of Alabama-Birmingham (UAB), Haque seeks to explain the presence and necessity of GIS in local governments. According to the author, government agencies now produce 90% or more of their own data and their desire to work with private providers has since overridden the need for the National Spatial Data Infrastructure (NSDI) that was established in 1994 by President Clinton.
GIS has allowed various local governments to work together, such as in Kent County, Michigan where 20 cities and townships have banded together to streamline issues such as road maintenance, environmental issues and expansion opportunities. It can also be seen in a web-mapping project undertaken by the county health department of Birmingham, Alabama, the EPA and the UAB where they post ozone information and provide hourly updates of air quality.
When considering the intersection of democratic values with GIS, Haque posits that it could have both positive and negative ramifications. On one hand, it could facilitate greater levels of individual participation in the democratic process; while on the other hand, it could concentrate critical information in the hands of the elite citizen base with access to GIS. There are real concerns that GIS is not–and will not be–a ‘technology of the masses’; therefore only a select few will understand its capabilities and this could lead to abusive power relations. However, it could also lead to the empowerment of communities when the ‘Force’ is used for good: maps can be generated to communicate specialized knowledge of areas/ecosystems; community profiles can be created easily; and the ability to share information with other localities can greatly increase.
GIS has significant implications for our modern democracy. The use of GIS in redistricting is powerful evidence of its worthiness and potential input to fair political decisions. It can also be a tool for resolving land disputes. Not too long ago 83% of Ellis Island was declared to be under the jurisdiction of New Jersey and GIS provided the data to settle this 160 year old dispute. GIS is also crucial in the request of capital development funds as in the majority of community and land improvement projects, maps are a significant requirement when the decision to allocate money takes place.
In a study done in the UK, GIS was shown to alleviate funding issues in the public sector. GIS has been used to help plan, develop and manage local assets; as well as to provide security for those assets, enhance capabilities of disaster forecasting and enable lower-cost citizen developed solutions. Many officials hoped to make it easier to share GIS data with other governing bodies and sub-contractors. These officials found that GIS had significantly improved efficiency in the transportation, flood management and recycling-waste management sectors.
In this case, it might be preaching to the choir to proclaim what GIS can do for the world. As GIS continues to become ‘mainstream’ and as its capabilities continue to be recognized and heralded, it’s clear that it will be pivotal in solving the problems of tomorrow. GIS can also be utilized to analyze historic problem solving practices to evaluate how issues were handled, and how they could have been better resolved. This type of historic modeling allows us to better anticipate the problems of tomorrow, and will thus help us find more efficient approaches to solving our impending challenges.
Justin Harmon
Staff Writer
The Kawah Ijen volcano resides in East Java, Indonesia, and towers to nearly 9,000 feet. Inside the volcano is a 200-meter deep lake of sulfuric acid. When the fumes are captured, they turn into a molten liquid and then solidify into pure sulfur. Miners then hack off chunks of the sulfur, braving dangerous gases with barely any protection. These miners then carry their load–upwards of 200 pounds–a few miles downhill, several times a day, to collect their pay–or about $5-10 USD per day. The noxious fumes that roll out of the volcano make it hard to breath and most miners develop very harsh coughs. The smell is pungent, and some describe it as suffocating–causing burning of the lungs. Filter masks are out of the question as it is too expensive to continually replace them.
The Ijen volcano is near the sleepy town of Sempol, more than 6,000 feet above sea level. From the town you take the Pos Paltuding trailhead to get to the crater. Nearly 400 men make this trek every day. The workers generally work for 2 weeks straight; sleeping in makeshift camps near the crater, then go home for 2 weeks to be with their families. The cycle repeats throughout the year.
Sulfur is commonly used in the bleaching of sugar, as well as for the vulcanization of rubber and of course in the manufacture of gunpowder. Another common use of sulfur is in the making of pulp and paper products. The release of sulfuric fumes is quite poisonous, as alluded to above; in 2006 alone, Canada released nearly 60,000 metric tons into the atmosphere. In a study done by the International Agency for Research on Cancer, they assessed mortality rates for workers exposed to sulfur dioxide in the pulp and paper industry in 12 countries. Their study included over 57,000 workers in a one year period, and their findings showed nearly 500 lung cancer deaths. Lung cancer mortality increased two-fold in among workers in the highest exposure category.
So it is safe to say that the Javanese workers on the volcanoes are likely putting themselves in great danger by not only working with sulfur and its fumes, but especially so by not using sufficient protection. But even as technology abounds in most extraction industries, no one has developed an efficient and safe way to collect sulfur. Sadly for the workers, in this region, this is considered one of the best ways to make a living.
For many people, manual labor is the only option to make a living. But when working in hazardous industries, with exposure to chemicals and noxious fumes, we typically see great consequences played out on workers’ health and life spans. In our country alone, tragedies in the mining industry have created headlines highlighting the danger that comes with this work. And for this we must ask ourselves, as did Aljazeera, is heavy manual labor disappearing or just becoming invincible?
In their documentary series, “Working Man’s Death,” an episode called ‘Ghosts’ highlights the struggle of the Javanese sulfur industry. It chronicles the daily routines and interviews workers who feel that this is their best option in life. They recount friends that have been lost when they fall on the steep and treacherous path up the volcano; and they downplay the effects of their exposure to the toxic fumes. But overall they are thankful to have this steady, if not difficult, work.
As the world continues to grow in population and industries expand, with it comes the need for more resources. It is not likely that we will see a reduction in dependence on our natural resources, so workers like those from Java will continue to put their health on the line just too eke out a living. In a way it is both a blessing and a curse; the demand keeps them employed, but the job costs them their lives in the long run. With growth we typically learn about our impact on the world around us, so perhaps there will be a move by those industries that indirectly employ these sulfur workers to improve their working conditions. Time will tell. For now, these ‘ghosts’ will continue to emerge from the overpowering, dark fumes to make their living.
Justin Harmon
Staff Writer
For this month’s Geospatial Frequently Asked Question (G-FAQ), I focus on a set of commonly confused terminology that relates to elevation data: contours, topos, DEMs and 3D. It seems that not a week goes by that I receive a request for elevation data where the client asks for a topo map (or topographic map); but based on their follow up questions and comments, it is clear that what they are asking for is elevation data in an alternate format. It seems that for many in our small industry, these terms are interchangeable when in reality they refer to very distinct forms of elevation data.
To help clear the confusion up, in this edition of G-FAQ, I address this core set of questions:
What do the terms contours, topographic map, digital elevation model (DEM) and 3-dimensional (3D) refer to and how are they created? Why are these terms so commonly confused? How are these terms related? When might you use each of these forms of elevation data?
To start off this discussion, there is a single theme that links all of these terms: they are all ways to represent and visualize the height of our surface’s planet. While this sounds like an easy task, in reality it is quite complex. Consider for example mapping a mountain on the Front Range of the Rocky Mountains. In many places, particularly towards the peak, the ground is too steep to even walk on. If you were able to measure elevation every meter you walked/crawled/climbed along this extremely steep sloping face, you would find places with changes in elevation of a meter or more, even over this short distance. Now, turn around and look at all of the micro-elevation changes that you missed in that meter, such as the large boulder you just climbed over. When you stop and consider the complexity of such a task, it becomes apparent that mapping elevation is not as straight forward as it sounds; and as you will see in this G-FAQ, contours, topographic maps, DEMs and 3D are meant for distinct purposes.
From the research I have done, it appears that contours were one of the earliest ways to represent elevation. A contour is created by connecting points of similar elevation with continuous circles. Contours create a strong visual sense of steepness and direction of slope as lines that are closer together show steeper slopes than lines that are farther apart. The first known contour map was created by a French engineer, Philippe Buache, in 1752 to map the depth of the English Channel. Before the advent of ‘modern’ mapping technology, a contour map was created by collecting spot elevations across a landscape and then manually interpolating the data. Contours were interpolated at a regularly spaced interval, for instance every 100 feet (i.e. the contour interval); and then transcribed to paper maps with labels at key elevations, for instance at 1000 feet. Depending on the scale of the map, an appropriate contour interval was chosen as map scale and accuracy are linked–see the USGS Map Accuracy Standards for more information on this topic.
Today, contours are still an important way to visualize elevation data, however we typically extract them from stereo imagery as DEMs are created. Further, most people have abandoned paper maps in favor of digital vector shapefiles that can be used in Geographic Information Systems (GIS). These digital vectors have elevation attributes embedded in them.
The next advance we find in visualizing elevation is the topographic map. A topographic map has the distinct characteristic of having contours present, but a true ‘topo map’ contains cultural, ecological and geographic information that contours alone would not purvey. The first topo maps created in the United States were the U.S. Coast Guard Survey topographic sheets, or ‘T-Sheets.’ There were 1,887 T-Sheets created from 1834 to 1911. In 1879, the USGS took over the responsibility of mapping our country and they created the best known topo maps that are still popular today, the 1:24,000 or 7.5-minute Quadrangle map series. Completed in 1992, it takes more than 55,000 maps to cover the lower 48 states.
Most of us are familiar with the 7.5-minute USGS map series with its fine contours lines overlain on pastel colors representing forests, rivers and marshes. These topo maps also feature building footprints, picnic areas, airports, dams and so much more. They were our country’s first attempt at creating a geographic database that included information on the slope and height of the land–its elevation–as well as information on its ecosystems, landforms and human-made structures. In a sense, it was our first attempt at creating ‘Google Earth,’ a tool that many of us use now to understand the landscape of distant and/or foreign lands without ever stepping our foot down in reality.
By combining all elements that comprise a landscape, the USGS topo maps are a powerful visualization tool still found in nearly every engineering office, university geography department and high school across the United States. Perhaps it is this familiarity with the topographic map that explains (at least in part) the use of ‘topo map’ to describe every form of elevation data. It is also the presence of contours on every topo map that would explain the interchangeability of these terms.
In next month’s edition of G-FAQ, I conclude this discussion on the visualization of elevation data with an explanation of DEMs and 3D as well as on the common use cases for each contours, topo maps, DEMs and 3D. Until then, Happy GIS-ing!
Do you have an idea for a future G-FAQ? If so, let me know by email at brock@apollomapping.com.
Find Out More About This Topic Here:
- Massachusetts Institute of–From Topographic Maps to Digital Elevation Models
- NOAA–Photo Library Voyage to Inner Space
- Penn State University e-Institute–Digital Elevation Model Lesson
- UN FAO–Elements of Topography
- University of Alabama Historical Map Collection–Coastal Topographic Sheets
- USGS–Topographic Map Standards
- USGS–Topographic Map Symbols
Brock Adam McCarty
Map Wizard
(720) 470-7988
New Radar Satellite Constellation Improves Coverage and Access
Astrium GEO-Information and Hisdesat, the Spanish government satellite service operator, have signed a framework agreement for a joint technology development project that aims to establish a constellation approach with the TerraSAR-X and PAZ radar satellites.
The German TerraSAR-X satellite was launched in 2007 and reliably delivers high-resolution radar data for versatile applications to customers around the world. PAZ is the first Spanish radar satellite designed as a dual-use mission to meet operational requirements, mainly of a defense and security nature, but also high-resolution civil applications.
PAZ is scheduled for launch in the first half of 2013 into a polar orbit specifically optimized to improve temporal resolution over key areas of interest when operating TerraSAR-X and PAZ as a constellation.
Combining Existing Missions into a Constellation
The agreement between Astrium and Hisdesat defines the joint development and coordination of their space, ground and service segments. The two satellite operators will establish interfaces enabling them to have a system overview of both satellites’ tasking plans and establish simplified data ordering and delivery procedures. The owner companies of the respective systems will retain complete control of their satellites, while being able to better coordinate acquisition planning and satellite tasking.
The cooperation will include the development of an aligned tasking approach for the two missions, harmonized ground segment operation, an integrated processor for both satellites as well as complementary order and delivery interfaces. The agreement also envisions joint marketing of products and services generated by the constellation approach.
Improved Revisit and Acquisition Capabilities
Operating the two virtually identical satellites will afford Astrium and Hisdesat more efficient and flexible management of system capacity. Both companies will be able to offer their customers and partners enhanced performance and services levels. The key advantages of the TerraSAR-X / PAZ constellation will be:
- Shorter revisit times
- Increased data acquisition capacities
- Improved service reliability
Shorter revisit times and increased capacity will provide improved levels of responsiveness and acquisition opportunities worldwide. The constellation will offer improved InSAR capabilities for precise monitoring and detection of faster surface-movement activities.
The constellation approach will also provide improved system redundancy and back-up for both satellites during maintenance phases.
Enhanced Applications
A wide range of time-critical and data-intensive applications will benefit from this constellation approach. The new TerraSAR-X / PAZ constellation will support reliable and rapid change detection and monitoring applications:
- Military and security operations will have access to substantiated ground information for mission management and will be able to react rapidly to new developments on the ground. Reduced lead times and reliable, faster coverage of critical AOIs and hot spots will support operational missions worldwide.
- Surface movement monitoring applications, which are already performed on basis of highly accurate TerraSAR-X data today, will be enhanced thanks to the improved revisit times. This will enable engineering and mining companies to efficiently monitor and manage their operations and avert damage to infrastructure and human lives.
- Enhanced revisit times and acquisition capacities support maritime surveillance applications including ship detection, oil pollution monitoring and sea ice observation.
With easy access to data from the high-resolution radar satellites, humanitarian organizations and crisis intervention will have faster and secure access to data over affected areas to support efficient coordination and management of rescue activities.
The PAZ (Spanish for “peace”) satellite will be launched in early 2013 into the same orbit as TerraSAR-X and TanDEM-X. PAZ is a dual-use mission designed to meet operational requirements, mainly of a defense and security nature but also with high-resolution civil applications.
The satellite structure is based on the TerraSAR-X satellite and was integrated by Astrium’s Friedrichshafen site in Germany, with the radar instrument being developed and integrated at the company’s Barajas facility. PAZ will be owned and operated by Hisdesat, which also holds the commercial exploitation rights for the mission. INTA, the Spanish Aerospace Technology Institute, is commissioned to develop and operate the satellites’ ground segment.
PAZ is the first Spanish radar satellite developed and implemented by the Spanish Ministry of Defense and the Ministry of Industry, Trade and Tourism as part of the National Earth Observation Program (PNOT). The second satellite in this program is INGENIO, an optical Earth-observation satellite mainly intended to serve civil purposes. The program will give Spain a fully independent operational satellite remote-sensing capability.
About TerraSAR-X
The TerraSAR-X Earth-observation satellite is a joint venture carried out under a public-private partnership between the German Aerospace Center DLR and EADS Astrium GmbH.
At DLR, a team of four institutes is responsible for implementing the mission in collaboration with the space agency. EADS Astrium GmbH developed, built and launched the satellite; the exclusive commercial exploitation rights are held by the geo-information service provider Infoterra GmbH, an Astrium subsidiary.
TerraSAR-X was launched in mid-2007 and has been in operational service since January 2008. As of June 2010, its “twin” TanDEM-X joined it in orbit. Together, the two satellites are collecting data for a global elevation model.
For more information about TerraSAR-X and PAZ, please contact the Apollo Mapping sales team at (303) 993-3863 or sales@apollomappoing.com.
As approved resellers of DigitalGlobe, Apollo Mapping is proud to offer imagery products from the first-ever 30-centimeter (cm) natural color orthoimagery layer covering the lower 48 states of the United States of America as well as significant portions of Western Europe. Scheduled to be completed by mid-2012, this impressive dataset will cover more than 10 million square kilometers (sq km) with an additional 6 million sq km of updated imagery to be collected over the next 30 months. Microsoft and DigitalGlobe have partnered on this long-term project, utilizing an exclusive aerial sensor–the UltraCamG–to collect the most accurate and visually appealing imagery available on the market.
The data included in the Precision Aerial imagery program can be grouped into three categories according to its collection and production specifications:
- High Value Areas (HVAs)
- These are dense urban centers and tourist destinations
- No clouds, cloud shadows, haze, smoke or pollution
- A horizontal accuracy of 2.7-meters (m) Circular Error 90% (CE90%)
- Leaf-off is required
- Free from standing water with only permanent snow and ice
- Data is processed and color balanced across the entire market
- Standard Blocks
- These are often suburban areas and smaller cities
- No clouds, smoke or pollution; and less than 2% cloud shadows and haze
- A horizontal accuracy of 4.0-m CE90%
- Leaf-off is desired
- Data is processed and color balanced by one-degree cells (~10,000 sq km)
- Remote Blocks
- These are rural areas
- Minimal amounts of clouds, cloud shadows, haze, smoke, pollution, standing water, snow and ice
- A horizontal accuracy of 5.3- m CE90%
- Leaf-off is not available
- Data is processed and color balanced by one-degree cells (~10,000 sq km)
The following specifications are universal across the Precision Aerial imagery dataset:
- Both 30-cm natural color and 60-cm color infrared (CIR) products are available
- Color balanced, seamless orthomosaics
- A projection/datum of UTM WGS84
In this regular monthly piece, we will provide our readers with an update on the progress of DigitalGlobe’s Precision Aerial imagery program, current coverage maps and full resolution previews of the data. If you would like more details on the coverage available in your area and/or on the pricing of the various delivery options, an Apollo Mapping representative would be happy to assist and can be reached by phone at (303) 993-3863 or email at sales@apollomapping.com.
April 2012–Coverage Statistics & Maps
- 10,180,000 sq km of 30-cm natural color and 60-cm CIR data acquired
- 8,445,000 sq km –loaded on DigitalGlobe’s cloud and streaming web services
- Key Areas Completed Acquisition in April
- Bern, Switzerland (HVA)
- Basel, Switzerland (HVA)
- Bismark, United States (HVA)
In the coverage maps below of DigitalGlobe’s Precision Aerial imagery over the United States and Europe, we have indicated the outlines of the HVAs and blocks that are a part of this program. Each of these outlines is color coded to indicate its current acquisition and/or delivery status.
In this new monthly piece, we provide details about updates released each month to Astrium GEO’s 2.5-meter (m) SPOTMaps product. SPOTMaps is an orthorectified natural color imagery layer with coverage over more than 100 countries–totaling an impressive 84 million square kilometers (sq km). For projects requiring a value-priced basemap better than what 15-m Landsat can offer, there is no other choice than SPOTMaps.
Key Product Specifications
- Resolution: 2.5-m
- Spectral Bands: simulated natural color (RGB)
- Horizontal Accuracy: 10 to 15-m RMSE (root mean square error)
- Projection/Datum: UTM WGS84
- Source Data: SPOT5 satellite imagery
- File Format: GeoTIFF
Product Differentiators
- Recent and ready for immediate delivery and integration with your GIS
- Seamless, orthorectified coverage across countries and entire regions
- Suitable for work up to 1:10,000 scale
- Custom product framing with minimum orders of ~100 sq km
- Product series is updated every month
- Source data can be delivered with all SPOTMaps mosaics
- Volume and academic discounts are offered
- Multi-user license are available
The map below has been color coded to show the collection year which makes up the majority of each SPOTMaps mosaic. An Apollo Mapping representative can provide more details on the specific year ranges used in each mosaic.
For this month’s Free For All!, I turn my attention north of the border to an impressive collection of free geospatial data for all of Canada. During the hunt for free Canadian GIS data, I ran across numerous such sites and chose GeoGratis for its ease of use, its search and download options and its Web Map Services (WMS) feed. A close second is GeoDiscover which contains more information than GeoGratis but is harder to navigate and lacks a WMS. Another nice option with GeoGratis is that users are not forced to register with the website to download data–which can save time when you are in a hurry to find the Canadian GIS data you need.
GeoGratis contains more than 100 collections of GIS data that can be accessed through a keyword search and by browsing the entire database in an alphabetic list. Once users ID the collection they are interested in, data is either downloaded by the province or through an FTP interface for more detailed products.
My favorite way to access this database is through the Toporama WMS. Here is a link to the English version of the WMS which gives you access to 16 Canadian data layers–including roads, vegetation, contours and hydrography–which can be toggled on and off in your GIS of choice:
http://wms.ess-ws.nrcan.gc.ca/wms/toporama_en
The WMS is scale dependent and rather responsive. You can find out more about the Toporama WMS here.
Brock Adam McCarty
Map Wizard
(720) 470-7988
With advent of new satellite data and products one begins to wonder “Will my geospatial software be able to read and display this data?” No one wants to buy something they won’t be able to view and manipulate with the programs they have already purchased. The programmers at Exelis appear to have anticipated this issue when it comes to TerraSAR-X/TanDEM-X data as they recently released a new reader that can be downloaded from their code library here.
This extension will become more useful as the two satellites continue to collect elevation data of the Earth. They recently completed their first full global-coverage collection with the twin satellites, which we discussed in our March 2012 Edition of The Geospatial Times–you can find this article here.