Have you checked out the new and improved Image Hunter yet?!?! If not, you should!
Listening to the feedback we received on improving imagery search engines, the new version of Image Hunter features a major overhaul to the user interface as well as to the backend architecture. Image Hunter Version 2 is built on open-source technology so now it works on all computers, not just on Windows machines. We slimmed down the user interface to make it easier to find the imagery filters and other available tools. All things said, we really think you will enjoy your browsing experience with Image Hunter (Version 2).
Image Hunter can be accessed 24 hours a day, 7 days a week and is a one-stop shop for every major source of medium and high-resolution satellite imagery on the market today, including:
- WorldView-2
- QuickBird
- WorldView-1
- GeoEye-1
- IKONOS
- The Pléiades 1 constellation
- The entire SPOT constellation
- RapidEye
If any of our readers have struggled with other geospatial search engines that are clunky, only query one data source and/or do not provide image previews, then Image Hunter is the solution to your woes, as it features:
- Online browsing of satellite imagery from 3 data providers and 14 satellites.
- Near-instantaneous loading of low resolution preview imagery with collection date, cloud cover and other key metadata.
- The ability to define your area of interest by address and with coordinates, geometric shape or shapefile/KMZ.
- A responsive basemap with street names to provide spatial context when discovering data as well as crowd-sourced updates for the most accurate map possible.
- Exports of the area of interest you create as well as the scenes you select in shapefile or KMZ format.
- Support for all operating systems, and not just our friends with Windows machines!
The new version of Image Hunter can be accessed here. We are excited to find out what you think about Version 2!
If you have any ideas and/or feedback to improve the new Image Hunter, please let us know at sales@apollomapping.com or (303) 993-3863.
Due to popular demand, significant imagery discounts for DigitalGlobe products are back! We expect these discounts to last till the end of 2014 so now is your time to take advantage of the deal if you missed out last year. In fact, no one has taken advantage of this discount offer yet which is surprising to us given how popular it was in 2013.
As a quick recap, this 50% off offer applies to purchases of 1,000 square kilometers (sq km) of satellite imagery that is older than 18 months, including WorldView-2, QuickBird, GeoEye-1, IKONOS and WorldView-1 data.
If you would like to check for coverage over your area of interest, give our online search engine, Image Hunter, a try. With Image Hunter, you can search for all DigitalGlobe satellite imagery quicker and easier than you can on their own site. It will literally only take a second or two to load all of the search results over your area of interest!
Here are the specifics on this DigitalGlobe imagery discount offer:
- Discount Offer: 50% off
- Regional Restrictions: US clients only
- Minimum Order: 1,000 sq km (across all polygons; at least 25 sq km per polygon)
- Age Restriction: greater than 18 months old
- Satellites Offered: WorldView-2, QuickBird, GeoEye-1, IKONOS and WorldView-1
- Products Offered: georeferenced panchromatic, natural color, 4-band pansharpened/bundle, 8-band bundle and stereo
- Promotion Dates: now through December 31, 2014
- Academic discounts still apply
If you would rather we check for coverage over your area of interest(s), no problem! Just send an email with your latitude/longitude coordinates, shapefile or KMZ to sales@apollomapping.com.
Do you send wires to Apollo Mapping? If so, please send us an email at sales@apollomapping.com and we will send you back our new wire transfer details! In the new wire transfer details, you will see there is no longer an intermediary bank which should make things much easier when sending us money.
Thanks to everyone for their continued patronage to Apollo Mapping!
We are pleased to announce that sales of the much anticipated WorldDEMTM produced by Airbus Defense and Space are under way! For the past three years, Airbus’ twin high-resolution radar satellites, TerraSar-X and TanDEM-X, have imaged the entire land surface of our planet multiple times to create the first ever global 12-meter (m) elevation model. The WorldDEM is ideal for all mapping projects requiring accurate elevation models including orthorectification, floodplain determination, mineral exploration and hydrocarbon development.
WorldDEM August 2014 Product Updates
During August, parts of Sub-Saharan Africa were made ready for production. Areas that are ready for production can be delivered within 4 to 8 weeks of ordering. These areas join large swaths of WorldDEM data ready for production over Australia, Canada eastern Europe, and the United States.
WorldDEM Specifications
The key product specifications of Airbus’ WorldDEM are as follows:
- Resolution: 12-m
- Coverage: entire landmass of the Earth, ~150 million square kilometers (sq km)
- Absolute Vertical Accuracy: < 4-m Linear Error 90% (LE90)
- Relative Vertical Accuracy: < 2-m LE90 (slopes ≤ 20%), < 4-m LE90 (slopes > 20%)
- Absolute Horizontal Accuracy: < 10-m Circular Error 90% (CE90)
- Vintage: all data collected within 3 years
- Source: interferometry from synthetic aperture radar (SAR) satellites TerraSAR-X & TanDEM-X
- Minimum Order: 500 sq km per polygon
- File Format: GeoTIFF
- Projection: geographic WGS84 (EGM2008, vertical datum), meter vertical unit
- Product Line Options:
- WorldDEMcore–unedited digital surface model (DSM), includes spikes, wells and voids
- WorldDEM–a DSM with removal of artifacts and water body flattening
- WorldDEM DTM–artifacts and surface features removed, i.e. a digital terrain model (DTM)
WorldDEM Coverage and Pricing
WorldDEM data has a 500 sq km minimum order size with a 10-km width requirement. Prices for two of the product lines have been set:
A coverage map of the one-degree cells that are currently ready for production. All of the cells on this map are either yellow (i.e. pre-production phase) or green (ready for production). Areas that are ready for production will take approximately four (WorldDEMcore) to eight weeks (WorldDEMTM) to deliver once an order is placed.- WorldDEMcore–$10.80 per sq km
- WorldDEMTM–$13.50 per sq km
Currently, there are portions of nearly every continent that are ready for production. In the coming months, the rest of the world will be released. For the estimated release dates of regions not currently ready for production, please email the Apollo Mapping team at sales@apollomapping.com.
WorldDEM Samples
You can download three 12-m WorldDEMTM samples here:
- Buraydah, Saudi Arabia–desert with agriculture present; 576 m to 737 m
- Mjosa Lake, Norway–hilly terrain with large water bodies; 100 m to 840 m
- Wagga Wagga, Australia–forest and urban with many water bodies; 137 m to 922 m
For more information about 12-m WorldDEM data, please send us an email at sales@apollomapping.com.
Starting October 1st, there are two important changes to DigitalGlobe satellite imagery pricing that should be noted by all of our readers:
- There will be a significant price reduction for archived and tasked 8-band WorldView-2 imagery.
- There will be a higher price for archived and tasked 40-centimeter (panchromatic) and/or 1.6-meter (multispectral) imagery.
In addition to these pricing changes, you are now able to task GeoEye-1 for single shot tasking.
If you would like specific details on the price changes and/or single shot GeoEye-1 tasking, please send us an email at sales@apollomapping.com.
Given the proprietary nature of DigitalGlobe’s price list, we are not able to publish these price changes in our newsletter; and we apologize for any inconveniences this may cause.
In August, we started a discussion on orthorectification in the Geospatial Frequently Asked Question (G-FAQ), and this month we conclude the two-part series. In the first part of the series, the focus was on the basics of orthorectification and how orthorectified data can be differentiated from georeferenced data. In this edition of the G-FAQ, we turn our attention to accuracy testing of orthorectified data. We also investigate RPC files which are often required to orthorectify imagery products.
As a quick reminder, we focus on these core questions in this two-part G-FAQ series:
What is the difference between georeferenced and orthorectified data? How is orthorectification completed and its accuracy tested? What are RPC files and how are they used in orthorectification?
In the August 2014 G-FAQ edition, we learned that georeferenced data has no accuracy guarantee. In order to have this assurance, imagery must be orthorectified; and to orthorectify imagery, you need a minimum of an elevation model and a camera model or rational polynomial coefficients (RPCs). In order to have the highest accuracy possible, you also need ground control points, a topic we will turn our attention to in the next G-FAQ series. For now, we can define ground control points as known locations on the surface of the planet with highly accurate XY (e.g. latitude and longitude) and Z (e.g. meters above sea level) survey coordinates.
Accuracy Testing of Orthorectified Imagery
Now let’s continue the discussion started last month with a look at accuracy testing of orthorectified imagery. In general, there are four factors which control the final accuracy of orthoimage. First, the image itself is a major contributing factor; and specifically, the off-nadir angle of the data and the topography it covers. Off-nadir is the angle the satellite was tilting when the imagery was collected, and for reference, zero degrees off-nadir would be pointing straight down at the ground. Imagery collected with a higher off-nadir (generally over 25 degrees) and/or over areas with lots of relief (such as mountains, hills and valleys) will be less accurate when orthorectified. Second, there is method used to orthorectify the imagery, and as was discussed last month, using a camera model in this process can result in a slightly more accurate final product. Third, the quality of the ground control used in orthorectification can impact accuracy. While we will not discuss control until next month, simply stated, the more accurate the ground control are, the more accurate the final orthoimage will be. Finally, there is the location and distribution of the ground control. If all of the control are clustered in the same small area, it can be accurate there but then far less accurate as you move away from this cluster. In general, the accuracy of orthoimage declines as you move away from the locations of ground control points (GCPs).
In order to test the accuracy of the orthoimagery you created, ground control points are required. Without ground control points, there is no way to assure accuracy in the final product so admittedly this is a bit of circular logic; and it can be rather frustrating when you lack this control. As such, for the next part of this discussion, let’s assume that you used ground control to create an orthoimage.
There are two ways to validate accuracy by using GCPs: the hold-out and the leave-one-out cross validation methods. In the hold-out method, accuracy is validated by taking a portion of the control you have, applying it to the imagery during orthorectification and then leaving out a subset to test the final accuracy once the ortho is complete. While this method has the advantage of being easy to compute, the disadvantage is that it can be unreliable as it depends on a set of control not used in the ortho process; and if there is a low number of GCPs for the project, these test points can be a poor, unrepresentative sample. The leave-one-out cross validation method is more complex to implement but it can have more reliable results. In this method, you test the accuracy of your orthoimage by subsetting out test control and control to be used in the ortho process, and then repeating this process multiple times–each time with a different subset of test control and control used to ortho.
Testing the accuracy of an orthorectified image is pretty straightforward once you determine the method to implement. Using the control you held out, the first step in accuracy testing is locating each test point in the orthoimagery. Once you have found the GCPs in your imagery, you will measure the straight line distance to its actual location on the ground. Each GCP’s actual location on the ground is determined by the XY (e.g. latitude and longitude; or northing and easting) coordinates recorded during the field survey. Repeat this process for each of your test points and record the measured distances in a spreadsheet.
Once you have the distances measured from the test GCPs to their actual locations on the ground, it is time to calculate an accuracy for your orthoimage. There are three common ways to report this accuracy: root mean square error (RMSE), circular error 90% (CE90%) and the US National Map Accuracy Standards (NMAS). Here is a brief description of each of these accuracy calculations:
A table showing the relationship between NMAS, CE90% and RMSE accuracy statements. You can see that as the map scale gets larger (e.g. moving from 1:12,000 to 1:4,800), the NMAS requires more accurate imagery.- RMSE – calculated as the square root of the sum of the straight-line differences of the X and Y coordinates of test control points and their ‘real’ position on the ground. Basically, this is the average distance your orthoimagery is off from its ‘real position’ on the ground.
- CE90%–a distance that defines the radius of a circle whereby 90% of test control points will fall within their ‘real’ ground positions.
- NMAS –this final way of reporting accuracy is more of a standard then it is a way to calculate this value. Established in 1947 by the USGS, the NMAS assures orthorectified imagery used by the Federal government meets certain accuracy requirements as its scale changes. Take for example an orthoimage with a maximum zoom scale of 1:4,800, according to the NMAS, this data should have a 13.33-foot CE90%. So then, for any given map scale, there is an accuracy standard (often reported in CE90%) that this data must adhere too. For more information about NMAS, please refer to this previous edition of the G-FAQ.
Before we move on from this subtopic, a few words to the wise about accuracy testing. First, while it seems that accuracy is a well-defined topic, it is rather flexible so to speak. And I say this as depending on what control you decide to use for accuracy testing, the results can be radically different. If you select test control points that are all in flat areas, you will find higher accuracies; and the converse is the same for selecting test control on hills and/or mountains (i.e. the accuracy will be lower). Second, as a general rule of thumb, it is often possible to get imagery collected by the newer satellites, WorldView-1/2 and GeoEye-1, within 2 or 3 pixels of their ‘real’ ground positions, assuming good GCPs and an elevation model are used in the process; and for the remaining satellites, a final accuracy within 5 pixels is often achievable.
A Primer on Rational Polynomial Coefficients (RPCs)
In the final section of this two-part series, let’s take a look at RPC files and their importance in orthorectification. Broadly speaking, RPC files are a way to describe the position of satellite imagery on the ground in a standardized and effective manner. A RPC file contains two equations which relates image space (i.e. the line and column position of a pixel) to object space (i.e. its latitude and longitude, northing and easting, etc.). One equation computes line position to X and the other column position to Y, both equations build out XY positions from the upper-left corner of an image. The coefficients for each of these two equations is calculated by the imaging companies and is based on the satellite’s position and orientation when the data was collected as well as the proprietary rigorous camera model.
RPC files then are generic equations for all sensors that are easy for commercial remote sensing software developers to implement. In many cases, these software makers will substitute RPC files for use in orthorectification as opposed to gathering proprietary camera models from each of the imaging companies (which can be a time consuming process). While the goal is to incorporate all of the factors considered in the rigorous camera model into a RPC file, there is a small difference between the two. This can result in a slightly larger residual error in the final orthoimage for the version produced with RPC files. As a final note, each imaging company has a slightly different format for RPC files–for example, DigitalGlobe calls them RPB files while Airbus delivers them in XML format.
In the next G-FAQ series, we will turn our attention to ground control points which are the secret ingredients to making extremely accurate orthoimagery.
Do you have an idea for a future G-FAQ? If so, let me know by email at brock@apollomapping.com.
Find Out More About This Topic Here
- Center of Geotechnologies, Riccardo Slvini–QuickBird Stereophotogrammetry for Geological Mapping
- DIIAR, Maria Antonia Brovelli–Accuracy Assessment of High Resolution Satellite Imagery
- Michigan Tech University–Photogrammetric Control Surveying
- Penn State University–Orthorectification
- Rutgers University–Geometric Correction of Imagery
- University of Oregon–Geometric Rectification
Brock Adam McCarty
Map Wizard
(720) 470-7988
brock@apollomapping.com

Here are two comparisons of 40-cm and 50-cm resolution WorldView-2 data collected over the Denver, Colorado metropolitan area on April 13, 2012. The GSD of these WV2 images is 46.4 cm. You will see that while the spatial extent changes from the 40-cm to the 50-cm tile, the center of the images remain unchanged. (Images Courtesy: DigitalGlobe)

Here are two comparisons of 40-cm and 50-cm resolution GeoEye-1 data collected over the Denver, Colorado metropolitan area on August 25, 2011. The GSD of these GE1 images is 41.4 cm. You will see that while the spatial extent changes from the 40-cm to the 50-cm tile, the center of the images remain unchanged. (Images Courtesy: DigitalGlobe)
Now that the US government has lifted the 50-centimeter (cm) resolution restriction on satellite imagery, it is time to compare 40-cm and 50-cm samples of GeoEye-1 (GE1) and WorldView-2 (WV2) data. In order to do this, we selected extremely low off-nadir GE1 and WV2 data collected over the Denver, Colorado metropolitan area and ordered each in 40-cm and 50-cm resolution. A matching color balance was then applied to each of the 40-cm and 50-cm datasets and animated GIFs were created to show the two images ‘side-by-side’.
Here are our thoughts about the comparison of 40-cm and 50-cm GeoEye-1 and WorldView-2 images:
- It is clear that 40-cm resolution matters with regards to the level of detail you can see and the maximum zoom (or map scale) possible with these images. However, it is unclear if you can actually see smaller features in 40-cm imagery than were visible in 50-cm imagery.
- Features at the edge of the detection limits in 50-cm imagery can now be discerned and identified with a higher level of confidence.
- However, all this said, there is only a portion of the GE1 and WV2 archive that should be produced at 40-cm resolution as imagery collected with a ground sampling distance (GSD) equal to or larger than 50-cm would make little sense to produce at a lower resolution. And similarly, in most cases, it would make little sense to produce an image with 49-cm ground sampling distance at 40-cm resolution and so on and so forth.
- Now let’s formalize the statement above with some statistics. In our eyes, only imagery with less than 45-cm GSD for GE1 and then 48-cm GSD for WV2 makes sense to produce at 40-cm resolution given the soon to be higher price for this data; but these cut-offs are obviously subject to the specific needs of your project. To this end, here is a breakdown of the GE1 and WV2 2014 archive (as of August 20th) by ground sampling distance.
- GE1
- Greater than or equal to 50-cm GSD–39.9%
- Less than 50-cm and greater than or equal to 45-cm GSD–38.2%
- Less than 45-cm GSD–21.9%
- WV2
- Greater than or equal to 50-cm GSD–78.9%
- Less than 50-cm and greater than or equal to 48-cm GSD–13.2%
- Less than 48-cm GSD–7.9%
If you have any questions about the images in this article or the changes in available resolution for GE1 and WV2, please send us an email at sales@apollomapping.com.
We are also happy to share the raw JPEGs used to create these animated GIFs if that would be an easier comparison for you, just send us an email to get them!
The Apollo Mapping sales team is curious what you think about these 40-cm versus 50-cm GE1 and WV2 images? If you have some feedback, feel free to leave us a post below!
- GE1
- Solar energy technology is always a hotbed of innovation so this month we turn our attention to advancements in this industry.First, here are a series of advancements that will make solar energy cheaper to produce. Connecting with last month’s focus on graphene, here is an idea to make solar panels cheaper by replacing expensive platinum dyes with 3-d graphene. By using abundant earth crust elements, scientists may be able to produce nanoparticle solar cells that can be painted onto surfaces. This research focuses on making low-cost plastic panels with two polymers.
Now here are several ideas to use solar energy to help those who are less fortunate. This Swedish water purifier uses ultraviolet radiation from the Sun to clean up to 11 liters of water in 2 to 6 hours. Here is a solar powered toilet that recycles water, produces hydrogen gas as waste is broken down and finally converts the waste to fertilizers. This research uses sunlight in a process similar to photosynthesis to produce an energy-rich liquid, methanol.
Finally, we take a look at three novel ideas to expand the reach of solar technology. University of Michigan researchers have developed colored solar panels which could be used to make beautiful stained glass in the near future. This idea embeds nanocrystals in windows to allow occupants to control the entry of visible light and/or the heat-producing near-infrared spectrum. Here is a novel approach to reducing the need for air conditioning by reflecting the heat produced by sunlight out of our atmosphere.
Here is an example of the map views you can create with the Cool Climate average carbon footprint website. (Map Credit: University of California, Berkeley)- This fun interactive map put together by the University of California, Berkeley breaks down average carbon footprint by zip code. I checked out my home zip code, 80302, and we are better than average with regards to our average footprint. You are also able to calculate your own estimated carbon footprint here. That said, any time an analysis of this size is completed, you have to take a minute and question the source of the data and its reliability on a nationwide scale.
- It’s time to pack up a lunch and send your kids back to school, and in honor of this yearly transition, this month I Googled, “GIS and high school.” After combing through the results, I found this interesting research on secondary education and GIS completed by Eyup Artvinli. This research was completed with the assistance of 665 Turkish students at 15 high schools. I wonder if Artvinli would have found the same results had he worked with 665 American high school students?
- From one of the East Coast’s premier cities, we travel west to the heart of the Midwest and review the online GIS resources of Michigan’s largest city, Detroit. For all of our readers that are pure GIS users, you will be happy to find this page full of shapefiles for nearly every geographic theme you can think of. And for those users who would prefer online maps and/or PDF versions of Detroit’s GIS files, here is a link you can check out. One drawback is that many of the links on this page appear to be broken.
Brock Adam McCarty
Map Wizard
(720) 470-7988
brock@apollomapping.com
===
Snippets of interest for the geospatial community.

